Listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Buzzsprout, online, or search ‘The Stewardology Podcast’ in your favorite podcast app.

 

Today’s episode is a listener request! Here is Kevin H’s question:

  • What are the pros and cons between a credit union and traditional bank and how they function? Both can be best utilized for being a good steward if used well when a person decides what type of financial institution to join – even if they decide to have both. 

Today, we want to discuss: Credit Unions vs. Traditional Banks

 

Credit Unions vs. Traditional Banks (The Main Differences)

The main differences between traditional banks and credit unions revolve around their structure, goals, services, and customer focus. Here are the key distinctions:

1. Ownership and Structure

  • Traditional Banks: These are for-profit institutions owned by shareholders. Their primary goal is to generate profit for their investors.
  • Credit Unions: These are non-profit organizations owned by their members (customers). Any profits made are returned to the members in the form of lower fees, higher savings rates, and lower loan rates.
    • These two areas are KEY differences…one brings profits to the shareholders, one returns profits 

2. Membership

  • Traditional Banks: Open to the general public. Anyone can open an account as long as they meet the bank’s requirements.
  • Credit Unions: Membership is often restricted to individuals who share a common bond, such as a specific community, employer, or organization. However, membership criteria can be quite broad, and many credit unions make it easy to join.

3. Profit Distribution

  • Traditional Banks: Profits are distributed to shareholders through dividends.
  • Credit Unions: Profits are returned to members through better interest rates on loans and deposits, and lower fees.

4. Governance

Both are typically governed by a board of directors, but:

  • Traditional Banks:Voting power is based on the number of shares owned.
  • Credit Unions: Each member typically has one vote, regardless of the amount of money they have deposited.

5. Services and Products

  • Traditional Banks: Often offer a wider array of services and products, including more complex financial instruments, investment services, and international banking.
  • Credit Unions: Tend to focus on more traditional banking services, such as savings accounts, checking accounts, loans, and credit cards. They may have fewer branches and ATMs compared to large banks.

6. Interest Rates and Fees

  • Traditional Banks: Generally charge higher fees and offer lower interest rates on savings due to their profit-oriented nature.
  • Credit Unions: Typically offer higher interest rates on savings and lower fees because they operate on a non-profit basis and aim to benefit their members.

7. Customer Service

  • Traditional Banks: Service can vary widely, but large banks may have a more impersonal feel due to their size.
  • Credit Unions: Often provide more personalized service, as they are smaller and community-focused, fostering a closer relationship with members.

8. Insurance

  • Traditional Banks: Deposits are insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) up to $250,000 per depositor.
  • Credit Unions: Deposits are insured by the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) up to $250,000 per depositor.

9. Technological Advancements

  • Traditional Banks: Typically have more resources to invest in the latest technology, offering advanced online and mobile banking services.
  • Credit Unions: May have fewer resources, sometimes resulting in less sophisticated technology offerings, though this is improving as technology becomes more affordable.

 

Which option would be better for me?

Choosing between a credit union and a traditional bank depends on your personal needs, financial habits, and priorities. Here are some factors to consider that can help you decide which option might be better for you:

Credit Union

Advantages:

  1. Lower Fees: Credit unions typically have lower fees for accounts and services.
  2. Higher Interest Rates on Savings: They often offer better interest rates on savings accounts and certificates of deposit (CDs).
  3. Lower Loan Rates: Credit unions usually provide lower interest rates on loans, including mortgages, auto loans, and credit cards.
  4. Customer Service: Credit unions are known for their personalized service and community focus.
  5. Membership Benefits: As a member, you have voting rights and can influence how the credit union is run.

Disadvantages:

  1. Limited Accessibility: They may have fewer branches and ATMs compared to large banks.
  2. Technology: Smaller credit unions might not offer as advanced online and mobile banking services as larger banks.
  3. Membership Restrictions: You might need to meet specific criteria to join, although many credit unions have broad eligibility requirements.

 

Traditional Bank

Advantages:

  1. Accessibility: Larger banks often have extensive branch networks and a large number of ATMs, making it easier to access your money.
  2. Technology: They typically offer more advanced online and mobile banking services, including sophisticated apps and a wider array of digital tools.
  3. Range of Services: Banks often provide a wider range of financial products and services, including investment services, wealth management, and international banking.
  4. Convenience: If you travel frequently or need access to services in multiple locations, a traditional bank might be more convenient.

Disadvantages:

  1. Higher Fees: Traditional banks often have higher fees for account maintenance, overdrafts, and other services.
  2. Lower Interest Rates: They tend to offer lower interest rates on savings accounts and CDs.
  3. Loan Rates: Interest rates on loans and credit cards may be higher compared to credit unions.
  4. Customer Service: Larger banks can sometimes provide less personalized service due to their size.

What about Christian Credit Unions?

Christian credit unions are financial institutions that operate with a mission to align their banking services with Christian values and principles. Christian credit unions specifically aim to provide financial services that reflect the teachings of the Bible and the ethical standards of the Christian faith.

Key Features of Christian Credit Unions:

  1. Faith-Based Mission:
    • Biblical Principles: Christian credit unions often base their operations on biblical principles such as stewardship, honesty, integrity, and love for neighbor. Their mission statements frequently emphasize serving members in a way that honors God and promotes financial stewardship.
    • Ethical Practices: These institutions are committed to ethical financial practices, avoiding investments or services that conflict with Christian morals (e.g., not financing businesses involved in gambling, pornography, or other industries considered immoral by Christian standards).
  2. Member Ownership and Community Focus:
    • Cooperative Model: Like all credit unions, Christian credit unions are owned by their members. Each member has a say in how the credit union is run, typically with one vote per member, regardless of the amount of money they have deposited.
    • Community Support: Many Christian credit unions are deeply involved in their communities, often providing support for local churches, Christian schools, and ministries. They may offer specialized financial products, such as loans for church buildings or programs to support missionary work.
  3. Products and Services:
    • Banking Services: Christian credit unions provide standard banking services like savings and checking accounts, loans, mortgages, and credit cards, often with competitive rates.
    • Stewardship Education: Many offer resources and programs focused on financial education from a Christian perspective, helping members manage their finances according to biblical principles. This can include workshops, counseling, and seminars on topics like debt management, budgeting, and charitable giving.
  4. Ethical Investment Options:
    • Socially Responsible Investing: Some Christian credit unions offer investment options that are screened to ensure they align with Christian values. This can include avoiding investments in companies that engage in practices contrary to Christian ethics.
    • Support for Ministry: Profits from these institutions may be reinvested into community development, charitable activities, or ministry support, aligning the credit union’s financial success with its mission to advance Christian values.
  5. Support for Churches and Ministries:
    • Church Loans: Many Christian credit unions offer specialized loans to churches for building projects, renovations, or other ministry needs, often with terms that reflect the unique nature of church finances.
    • Ministry Accounts: They may also offer accounts tailored to the needs of ministries, such as special savings accounts for missions, benevolence funds, or accounts designed for managing tithes and offerings.

Examples of Christian Credit Unions:

  • Christian Community Credit Union (CCCU): One of the largest Christian credit unions in the United States, CCCU offers a range of financial products and services, all designed with the goal of helping members practice biblical financial stewardship. They are known for their involvement in mission support and providing loans to churches and Christian schools.
  • America’s Christian Credit Union (ACCU): ACCU provides similar services, with a focus on supporting Christian ministries, churches, and families. They offer a variety of accounts and loans, including adoption loans and church loans.

Biblical Perspective:

Christian credit unions seek to embody the principles of biblical stewardship, which is the responsible management of resources that God has entrusted to us. The Bible encourages believers to be wise with their finances, avoiding debt whenever possible (Proverbs 22:7) and being generous with others (2 Corinthians 9:7). By offering financial services that align with these values, Christian credit unions aim to help their members honor God with their money.

Additionally, Christian credit unions provide a practical way for believers to live out their faith in the financial realm, ensuring that their banking and investments are consistent with their Christian values. This can be seen as an extension of the call to “seek first the kingdom of God and His righteousness” (Matthew 6:33) in all areas of life, including finances.

 

Questions to Ask Yourself

  1. What are my banking needs?
    • Do I need a wide range of services, or do I just need basic checking and savings accounts?
    • How important are low fees and higher interest rates on savings?
  2. How important is accessibility?
    • Do I need a bank with a large number of branches and ATMs?
    • How frequently do I rely on in-person banking versus online services?
  3. What is my preference for customer service?
    • Do I prefer personalized service and a community focus, or is efficiency and convenience more important to me?
  4. What are my technology needs?
    • How important are advanced online and mobile banking services to me?
    • Do I need features like mobile check deposit, person-to-person payments, or comprehensive financial management tools?
  5. Do I want my banking to replicate my faith values?
    • If you do, then consider looking into a faith based credit union where not only can you get decent banking, but also allow your money that is there in the bank to be used for greater church and Kingdom works!

Stewardship Application

If you value lower fees, higher savings rates, and personalized service, and you don’t mind potentially fewer branches and somewhat less advanced technology, a credit union might be the better choice. If you need extensive accessibility, a wide range of services, and advanced digital tools, and you are okay with potentially higher fees, a traditional bank might be more suitable.  If you are passionate to have your banking dollars used for greater church and Kingdom works, consider one of the many Christian Credit Unions.

Ultimately, consider checking out all three…the local credit union, the traditional bank and the national Christian Credit Union to discuss your needs and see what specific services and benefits they can offer you.

 

 

Next Steps

 

Material presented is property of The Stewardology Podcast, a ministry of Life Financial Group and Life Institute. You may not copy, reproduce, modify, create derivative works, or exploit any content without the expressed written permission of The Stewardology Podcast. For more information, contact us at Contact@StewardologyPodcast.com or (800) 688-5800.

The topics discussed in this podcast are for general information only and are not intended to provide specific investment advice or recommendations.Investing and investment strategies involve risk including the potential loss of principal. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results.

Securities and advisory services offered through GWM, Inc Member FINRA/SIPC